Globalization of the Plea Bargaining: Lessons From Countries With Unlimited System

 Law in the process of globalisation (2018), (стр. 177-200) 

АУТОР: Veljko Turanjanin

Е-АДРЕСА: vturanjanin@jura.kg.ac.rs

Download Full Pdf   

DOI: 10.46793/LawPG.177T

САЖЕТАК:

Plea bargaining is a global phenomenon among legal transplants of the criminal procedural law. It originated on the American continent, but become popular in the last 30 years around the world. Legislators, faced with the overloaded courts, found solutions in the comparative law that could solve this problem. Plea bargaining is far away from the perfect system of the solving criminal cases, since many critics follow this transplant. However, its positive sides are numerous, so it comes to life in every country where it is introduced. Of course, some states started from the beginning with rapid changes in legislations, completely turning its legal system to the Anglo-American. Others moved with significantly more caution, limiting plea bargaining on certain crimes. The author in this work deals with the agreement in countries with unlimited system of plea bargaining: Germany, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Serbia.

КЉУЧНЕ РЕЧИ:

plea bargaining, plea agreement, negotiation, limited and unlimited system, felony

ЛИТЕРАТУРА: 

  • Banovic, B., Turanjanin, V., Euthanasia: Murder or Not, Iranian Journal of Public Health, 10/2014, 1316-1323.
  • Bittmann, F., Consensual Elements in German Criminal Procedure Law, German Law Journal, vol. 15, no. 1, 2014.
  • Bohnalder, M., Principles of German Criminal Law, Oxford – Portland, 2009.
  • Cambj, N., Sporazumijevanje prema noveli Zakona o kaznenom postupku, Hrvatski ljetopis za kazneno pravo i praksu, Vol. 20, No. 2/2013.
  • Coleman, W., Sajed, A., Fifty Key Thinkers on Globalization, Oxon, 2013.
  • Colin, M., Deal or no deal: why courts should allow defendants to present evidence that they rejected favorable plea bargains, American Criminal Law Review, 2011.
  • Cvorovic, D., Turanjanin, V., Principle of the Opportunity as a Diversion Form of Criminal Procedure, in: Arhibald Reiss Days, Vol. III, 2015, 317-328.
  • Đurđić, V., Sporazum o priznanju krivice, Revija za kriminologiju i krivicno pravo, 3/2009.
  • Epp, J. A., Building on the Decade of Disclosure in Criminal Procedure, London – Sydney, 2001.
  • Fätkinhäuer, H. J., pseudonym Detlef Deal, Der strafprosessuale Vergleich, StrVert, 1982.
  • Feeley, M., Perspectives on plea bargaining, Law & Society Review, Vol. 13, No. 2, Special issue on plea bargaining, 1979, 199-209.
  • Felstiner, W., Plea contract in the West Germany, Law & Society Review, Special issue on plea bargaining, Vol. 13, No. 2, 1979, 309-325.
  • Govedarica, M., Donošenje presude bez suđenja u krivičnom postupku Republike Srpske, Pravna riječ, 15/2008.
  • Heller, M., Das Gesetz zur Regelung der Verständigung in Strafverfahren – No big deal?, Hamburg, 2012.
  • Hermann, J., Bargaining Justice – A Bargain for German Criminal Justice, University Pittsburg Law Review, 1992.
  • Ikanović, V., Pregovaranje o krivici nakon desetogodišnje primjene u Bosni i Hercegovini, u: Pojednostavljene forme postupanja u krivičnim stvarima: regionalna krivičnorocesna zakonodavstva i iskustva u primeni, Beograd, 2013.
  • Janković, R., Mogućnost žalbe protiv presude kojom se optuženi oglašava krivim na osnovu sporazuma o priznanju krivice, Pravna riječ, 29/11.
  • Kadiev, D., Postupak dogovora o krivici a aspekta branioca, u zborniku: Pojednostavljene forme postupanja u krivičnim stvarima, Beograd, 2013.
  • Karioth, D., Absprachen im Strafprozess mit rechtsvergleichendem Blick auf das „plea bargaining” im anglo-amerikanischen Strafprozess, in: R. Ooyen, M. Möllers, Arbeiten zu Studium und Praxis im Bundesgrenzschhutz, Lübeck 1999/2000, 114-145.
  • Kaurinović, D., Praktična iskustva u primjeni novih krivičnoprocesnih ustanova: priznanje krivice, sporazum o priznanju krivičnog dela i kazneni nalog, u: Aktuelna pitanja primjene krivičnog zakonodavstva u BiH, Neum, 2004.
  • Kerscher, M., Plea Bargaining in South Africa and Germany, Stellenbosch, 2013.
  • Kolaković-Bojović, M., Completion of Criminal Proceedings in Reasonable Time (Okončanje krivičnog postupka u razumnom roku, Beograd), doctoral dissertation, University of Belgrade, Faculty of Law, 2016.
  • Kolaković-Bojović, M., Efikasnost krivičnog postupka, reforma pravosuđa i pristupni pregovori sa EU, Zbornik Instituta za kriminološka i sociološka istraživanja, Vol. 33, No. 2/2014.
  • Kolaković-Bojović, M., Efikasnost krivičnog pravosuđa kao sredstvo suzbijanja kriminaliteta, u: Kriminal i društvo Srbije: izazovi društvene dezintegracije, društvene regulacije i očuvanja životne sredine (Hugson, M. & Stevanović, Z. ur.) Institut za kriminološka i sociološka istraživanja, Beograd, 2015.
  • Kolaković-Bojović, M., Pojam efikasnosti krivičnog postupka-razumemo li ideal kome težimo, u: Kriminal, državna reakcija i harmonizacija sa evropskim standardima, (Kron, L. ur.), Institut za kriminološka i sociološka istraživanja, Beograd, 2013.
  • Krey, V., Windgätter, O., The Untenable Situation of German Criminal Law: Against Quantitative Overloading, Qualitative Overcharging, and the Overexoansion of Criminal Justice, German Law Review, Vol. 13, No. 06, 2012.
  • Küpper, G., Konflikt oder Konsens, HFR 14/2007.
  • Langer, M., From Legal Transplants to Legal Translations: The Globalization of Plea Bargaining and the Americanization Thesis in Criminal Procedure, Harvard International Law Journal, Vol. 45, No. 1/2004.
  • Maynard, D., Demur, Defer, and Deter: Concrete Actual Practices for Negotiation in Interaction, Negotiation Journal, April 2010.
  • Mursch, H. P., Grundregeln bei Absprachen im Strafverfahren, Zeitschrift fur Rechtpolitik
  • Nedić, D., Aktuelna pitanja glavnog krivičnog postupka sa aspekta javnog odnosno državnog tužioca, u: Mogući pravci razvoja jugoslovenskog kaznenog zakonodavstva i njihove osnovne karakteristike, Beograd, 1999.
  • Nikolić, D., Sporazumi o priznavanju krivičnog dela kao reprezentativna forma pojednostavljenog postupanja u krivičnim stvarima, Pojednostavljene forme postupanja u krivičnim stvarima: regionalna krivičnoprocesna zakonodavstva i iskustva u primeni (ur. I. Jovanović, M. Stanisavljević), Beograd, 2012.
  • Novković, M., Normativna i praktična iskustva u regulisanju i primjeni sporazuma o priznavanju krivice kao novog instituta krivičnog procesnog prava u BiH, Bilten Okružnog suda u Banjoj Luci, 2-4/2006.
  • Petegorsky, M. N., Plea Bargaining in the Dark: The Duty to Disclose Exculpatory Brady Evidence during Plea Bargaining, Fordham Law Review, vol. 81, 2013.
  • Rauxloh, R., Formalization of Plea Bargaining in Germany – Will the New Legislation Be Able to Square the Cricle?, Fordham International Law Journal, Vol. 34, 2010.
  • Rosenau, H., Die Absprachen im deutschen Strafverfahren, in: H. Rosenau, S. Kim, Strafttheorie und Strafgerechtigkeit, Frankfurt, 2010.
  • Rosenau, H., Die Absprachen in Deutchland, Law&Justice Review, vol. 1, 2010.
  • Safferling, C., Hoven, E., Plea Bargaining in Germany after the Decision of the Federal Constitutional Court, German Law Journal, Vol. 15, No. 1, 2014.
  • Schünemann, B., Ein deutsches Requiem auf den Strafprozess des liberalen Rechtsstaats, Zeitschrift fur Rechtspolitik, Vol. 42, 2009.
  • Siegismund, E., The Public Prosecution Office in Germany: Legal Status, Functions and Organization, 120th International Senior Seminar Visiting Experts’ Papers, Resource Material Series No. 60, 2003.
  • Sijerčić-Čolić, H., Simović, M., Kaurinović, D., Komentari zakona o krivičnom/kaznenom postupku Bosne i Hercegovine, Sarajevo, 2005.
  • Simonović, B., Turanjanin, V., Sporazum o priznanju krivičnog dela i problemi dokazivanja, u: Kriminalistički i krivičnoprocesni aspekti dokaza i dokazivanja, Sarajevo, 2013.
  • Simović, M., Pojednostavljene forme postupanja u krivičnom procesnom zakonodavstvu Bosne i Hercegovine (zakonska rješenja i iskustva u dosadašnjoj primjeni), u: Alternativne krivične sankcije i pojednostvljene forme postupanja (ur. S. Bejatović), Beograd, 2009.
  • Simović, M., Simović, V., Napomene o sporazumima u krivičnom postupku, u: Krivično zakonodavstvo Srbije i standardi Evropske unije (ur. S. Bejatović), Kragujevac, 2011.
  • Škulić, M., Komentar Zakonika o krivičnom postupku, Beograd, 2009.
  • Škulić, M., Osnovi uporednog krivičnog procesnog prava i problemi reforme krivičnog postupka, u: Kaznena reakcija u Srbiji I (ur. Đ. Ignjatović), Beograd, 2011.
  • Turanjanin, V., European Systems of Jury Trials, US-China Law Review, 2/2015.
  • Turanjanin, V., Eutanazija i lekarski potpomognuto samoubistvo pod lupom Evropskog suda za ljudska prava, u: Krivičnopravni instrumenti suprotstavljanja terorizmu i drugim krivičnim djelima nasilničkog karaktera, Banja Luka, 2016.
  • Turanjanin, V., Jury Systems in Europe as the Anglo-Saxon Type of Trial, in: Arhibald Reiss Days, Vol. III, Belgrade, 2014.
  • Turanjanin, V., Mihajlovic, B., Right to die with Dignity – the Same Problems and Different Legal Approaches in European Legislations, with Special Regard to Serbia, in: Human Rights between War and Peace, Vol. 2, 2015.
  • Turanjanin, V., Plea Bargaining, doctoral dissertation, Faculty of Law University Kragujevac, Kragujevac, 2016.
  • Turanjanin, V., Pozitivnopravno regulisanje specifične medicinske usluge u Sjdinjenim Američkim Državama, u: XXI vek – vek usluga i uslužnog prava (ur. M. Mićović), Kragujevac, 2012.
  • Turanjanin, V., Sporazum o priznanju krivice u krivičnom procesnom pravu Nemačke, u: Nova rešenja u kaznenom zakonodavstvu Srbije i njihova praktična primena, Zlatibor, 2013.
  • Turanjanin, V., Transplantacija sporazuma o priznanju krivice kroz zemlje anglo-saksonskog pravnog sistema, u: Pravna misao u srcu Šumadije (ur. B. Vlašković), Kragujevac, 2012.
  • Turanjanin, V., Vostinic, M., Zarkovic, I., Evidences and the New Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Serbia, in: Researching Security: Approaches, Concepts and Polices, Skopje, 2016.
  • Turner, J. I., Can We Manage Plea Bargaining Better? Insights from Germany, Paper presented at the annual meeting of the the Law and Society, 2009, http://www.law.smu.edu/faculty/Turner, November 2011.
  • Turner, J. I., Judicial Participation in Plea Negotiations: A Comparative View, The American Journal of Comparative Law, Vol. 54, 2006.
  • Weigend, T., The Decay of the Inquisitorial Ideal: Plea Bargaining Invades German Criminal Procedure, in: J. Jackson, M. langer, P. Tillers, Crime, Procedure and Evidence in a Comparative and International Context – Essays in Honour of Professor Mirjan Damaška, Oxford – Portland, 2008.