CONSTITUTION, MORALS AND ETHICS

Зборник радова „Устав СФРЈ из 1974. године – 50 година касније“, 2025 (стр. 85-110)

AUTHOR(S) / АУТОР(И): Alexios Panagopoulos , Vassilios Anyfantis

Download Full Pdf   

DOI: 10.46793/Ustav74.085P

ABSTRACT / САЖЕТАК:

The article refers to the sensitive relationship of the constitution with morals and ethics. The rules of ethics derive from the conscience of each person, which becomes the natural lawgiver and judge of his actions, which is why a state of law must develop the moral self-awareness of its citizens. The center of our search also concerns the question of whether and to what extent the constitutions of European states, when indeed the concept of the rule of law prevails, if they finally accept individual morality and ethics and to what extent they can impose certain moral standards. Scientific research shows that modern and contemporary constitutional legislators tend to be self-restrained and neutral on the issues of morality, avoiding to legislate specific moral values. The statement applies both to constitutional rights and to the public and administrative organizational part, with some special nuances for private and public life. Our reflection concerns the European constitutional and international space, up to the legal framework of the European and American constitution. Human constitutional rights have a prominent place in our research, as they arise from the application and combined interpretation of the constitution for the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the constitutional Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. We conclude that legislative and constitutional value is aided by the formation of personal morality and ethics towards our fellow human beings. The position of ethics in constitutional public life is also examined, where self-restraint should prevail in matters of public political ethics, without ignoring that what is being sought is the due fight against public political corruption and care for the sanitization of constitutional political morals.

KEYWORDS / КЉУЧНЕ РЕЧИ:

Constitution, morals, ethics, political corruption, public sanitation

REFERENCES / ЛИТЕРАТУРА

  • Aristotle: Aristotle, Politics II.2, translation: Vasilis Moskovis, 1261a 15-22.
  • Beis: Con. Beis, Rule of Law and Moral Value, https://pergamos.lib.uoa.gr/uoa/ dl/object/2959169/file.pdf (21.09.2024).
  • Alexy : Robert Alexy, „The right and the right“, Isopoliteia 3 (1999), 11.
  • Annas: Julia Annas, An Introduction to Plato’s Republic, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1981.
  • Audi: Robert Audi, Epistemology: A Contemporary Introduction to the Theory of Knowledge, London & New York, Routledge, 1998,
  • Garnsey: Garnsey Peter – Saller Richard, The Roman Empire Economy, Society and Culture, translated by : B. I. Anastasiadis , editor : G. A. Souris, Heraklion, University Editions Crete, 2001.
  • Gourbeillon Annie, Precis d’ histoire grecque (2000-31 BC). Du debut du deuxieme millenaire a la bataille d’ Actium, translation Lydia Stefanou, Athens, Papadima, 2002.
  • Gryntakis: Gryntakis G. Dalkos G. Hortis A., Social and Political Organization in Ancient Greece, Greek Ministry of Education Textbook Publishing Organization, for the 2nd grade of Lyceum, Athens 1998.
  • Dritsa: Dritsa D. L. – Moschou D. – N. Papalexandropoulos S. L., Christianity and Religions, Educational Books Publishing Organization of the Ministry of Education of Greece, Athens.
  • Delivogiatzis:  Delivogiatzis  Sokratis,  Issues  of  Dialect,  third  edition,  Thessaloniki, Zitros, By the same, The natural and the human, Thessaloniki, Publications: Erodios, 2002.
  • Edgar : Poe Allan Edgar, The Raven, translated by Panos Panasis, Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki Publishing.
  • Godding: Philippe Godding, „Jurisprudence et motivation des sentences, du moyen-âge à la fin du 18ème siècle“, in Chaïm Perelam & Paul Foriers (eds.), La motivation des décisions de justice, Brussels, Emile Bruylant, 1978,
  • Brown: Harold I. Brown, Rationality, London & New York, Routledge, 1988.
  • Broome: John Broome, Rationality Through Reasoning, Oxford, Wiley-Blackwell, 2013. Descartes: Rene Descartes, Discourse on Method (1637), Principles of Philosophy (1644).
  • Iosif: Iosif Solomon & Gerasimos Kouzelis (eds.), Discipline and Knowledge, Athens, Society for the Study of Human Sciences, 1994.
  • Hufteau: Yves-Louis Hufteau, Le référé législatif et les pou no irs du juge dans le silence de la loi, Paris, Presses Universitaires de France, 1965.
  • Hunt: HAC Hunt, A physical interpretation of the universe: The doctrines of Zeno the Stoic. Kant: Kant Immanuel, Die Religion innerhalb Grenzen der blossen Vernunft, transl Kostas Androulidakis, Athens, Polis, 2007.
  • Kiritsaka: Evas Kiritsaka: https://dikastirio.com/dikaio-kai-ithiki/ (17.09.2024).
  • Kennedy: Kennedy EJ – Claussen WV, The Cambridge history of classical literature II: Latin Literature, trans. Th. Pikoula – A. Sideri – Tolia, edited by A. Stefani, Athens, Publications: Papapadima, 2000.
  • Lesky: Lesky Albin, Geschichte der griechischen Literatur, trans. Dear G.Tsopanakis, Thessaloniki, Kyriakidis Brothers.
  • Letsas: George Letsas, A Theory of Interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2007.
  • Magee: Bryan Magee et al., Men of Ideas (New York: Viking Press, 1979), 137.
  • Montesquieu: Montesquieu Charles De Secondat Baron De, De l’ esprit des lois, Knowledge , 2006
  • Manos: Manos Andreas, In many – the function of intoxication in the metaphysical system of Proclus, Athens, Edition: Grigori, 2004.
  • Manos: Manos Andreas, Eudaimonia as breadth of life in ancient Stoic philosophy, Athens, Edition: Kardamitsa, 2002.
  • Manos: Manos Andreas, The metaphysics of art and beauty in the light of ancient Greek philosophy, Athens, Published by: Association for the Distribution of Beneficial Books, 1999.
  • Manos: Manos Andreas, The ontology of evil according to Plotinus. Ethical and metaethical echoes, Athens, Edition: Kardamitsa, 2002.
  • Manos: Manos Andreas, Pre-Socratic, Platonic and Post-Platonic intellect. Evaluative research, Athens, Publications: Giorgos Dardanos, 2001.
  • Mayer: Theo Mayer – Maly, Rechtswissenschaft, Munich, Oldenbourg, 2nd ed., 1981, inckelmann, 5th ed., Tübingen, J . C. B. Mohr, 1976.
  • Mele: Alfred R. Mele – Piers Rawling (edited ), The Oxford Handbook of Rationality, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2004
  • Menne: Albert Menne, Einführung in die Methodologie, Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1984.
  • Nagel: Thomas Nagel, The Last Word, News York/Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1997. Nesselrath: Nesselrath Heinz – Gunther, Einleitung in die griechische Philologie, trans. Ioannis
  • Anastasiou, Ioannis Vasis, Sofia Kotzampasi, Theokritos Kouremenos, Pulcheria Kyriakou, editor: Daniel I. Iacov – Antonis Regakos, Athens, Publications: Papadima, 2001.
  • Nikolaidis: Nikolaidis Tassos Puella Formosa. The feminine beauty in Catullus and the Roman elegiacs, Athens, Publications: Stigmi, 1994.
  • Nozick: Robert Nozick, The Nature of Rationality, Princeton , NJ, Princeton University Press, 1995.
  • Ostrogorsky: Ostrogorsky Georg, Geschichte des byzantinischen Staates, Volume 1-3, trans. John Panagopoulos, scientific Supervision: Evangelos K.Chrysos, Athens, Publications: Vassilopoulos.
  • Homer: Homer, Odyssey, translated by Zisimos Sideris, Athens, Organization of Educational Books Publications of the Ministry of Education of Greece, Athens.
  • Oscar: Wilde Oscar, The picture of Dorian Grey, translated by Tina Stefanopoulou, Published by: Eleftherotypia, Athens 2006.
  • Panagopoulos: Alexios Panagopoulos, Contemporary Political and Constitutional Institutions, Achaikes Publications 1996.
  • Panagopoulos: Alexios Panagopoulos, Introduction to Law and the Science of Law, Patras 1997.
  • Panagopoulos: Alexios Panagopoulos, Human Rights, Athens 2023.
  • Panagopoulos: Panagopoulos Alexios, Ancient Sparta – Society and Law, Achaikes Editions 1995.
  • Papagiannis: Papagiannis Lambros, Work in the Course of Platonic Philosophy, Thessaloniki, 2007.
  • Papadopoulou: Papadopoulou Teta, by Cornelios Kastoriadis, Athens, Polis, 2000.
  • State: State, Electronic Journal of Public Law, Athens 2024, Issue 10, April 2024. (https://www.epoliteia.gr/e-journal/2024/04/22/e-politeia-teyxos-10-aprilios-iounios-2024/ (18.09.2024).
  • Plangesis: Plangesis Ioannis, History of Philosophy vol. II. Newer Political Philosophy (from Machiavelli to Marx), Thessaloniki, 2005.
  • Prevedourou: Eugenia Prevedourou – Giorgos Karavokyris, in the 10th issue of the e-Politeia Public Law electronic magazine, https://www.epoliteia.gr/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/ e_politeia_teyxos_10-1.pdf (18.09.2024 )
  • Raz: Joseph Raz, “The Autonomy of Legal Reasoning,” Ethics in the Public Domain: Essays in the Morality of Law and Politics, revised edition, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995.
  • Rapp: Friedrich Rapp, entry ‘Methode’, in Hermann Krings (ed.), Handbuch philosophischer Grundbegriffe, Munich, Kösel, 1973, vol . 4.
  • Rapp: Friedrich Rapp, entry ‘Methode’, in Hermann Krings (ed.), Handbuch philosophischer Grundbegriffe, Munich, Kösel, 1973, vol . 4, p .913. See: about methodology Albert Menne, Einführung in die Methodologie, Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1984.
  • Rawls: Rawls John, Theory of Justice, translation: Filippos Vasilogiannis, Vassilios Voutsakis, Filimon Paionidis, Konstantinos Papageorgiou, Nikolaos Stylianidis, Andreas Takis (Athens: Publications: Polis, 2010, First Edition 2001).
  • Regelsberger: Ferdinand Regelsberger, General teachings on the law of the Pandektes, translated by Geo. Maridaki – Chr. Pratsika, In Athens, Embros, 1915.
  • Ricoeur: Paul Ricoeur, “On John Rawls’ a Theory of Justice: Is a pure Procedural Theory of Justice Possible?“ International Social Science Journal 126 (1990): 563.
  • Sandel: Michael Sandel, Justice. What Is Right? Translation: Alexandros Kiupkiolis (Athens: Polis Publications, 2011), 212.
  • Sofokles: Sofokles, Antigone, translated by K.X.Myris, Athens, Organization of Publications of Didactic Books of the Ministry of Education of Greece, Athens 1998.
  • Savvantidis: Paschalis M. Savvantidis G. Latin (with an introduction by Nikitas D. Z.), Educational Books Publishing Organization of the Hellenic Ministry of Education, Athens. Pospicil: Leopold Pospicil, Anthropologie des Rechts (Munich: Harper and Row Publishers Inc, 1982).
  • Sakkoulas: Sakkoulas, Legal Publications, https :// www . sakkoulas . gr / el / editions / v – skouris – syntagma – kai – ithiki -2024/ (18.09.2024)
  • Skouris: Vassilios Skouris, Constitution and Ethics, Athens, 2024.
  • Skouris: Vassilios Skouris https :// www . vassiliosskouris . com / post / syntagma – kai – h 8 ikh – oi – kanones – ths – h 8 ikhs – ston – idiwtiko – kai – dhmosio – bio (18.09.2024)
  • Sauve : Sauve J – M ., La Cour de justice de Union europ é enne sous la pr é sidence de Vasilios Skouris [2003-2015] – Liber amicorum Vasilios Skouris, for the former president of the European Court of Justice, 2015.
  • Schmidt: Schmidt-Aßmann, E., “Actions founded sur l’atteinte à un droit (“Verletztenklagen”) et actions conditionnées only par un intérêt à agir (“Interessentenklagen”), en contentieux administrative. Entre tradition et innovation“, in to, Le droit européen, source de droits, source du droit : mélanges en l’honneur de Vassilios Skouris, 2022.
  • Sourlas: Paul Sourlas, Rechtsprinzipien als Handlungsgründe (Baden Baden: Nomos, 2011), 119-122, https://www.nomos-shop.de/en/p/rechtsprinzipien-als-handlungsgruende-gr-978-3-8329 -6658-4 (21.09.2024).
  • Sourlas: Paul Sourlas, „Le rôle des précédents: Quelques réflexions générales inspirées de l’exemple grec“, in Ewoud Hondius ( ed .), Precedent and the Law, Brussels , Bruylant, 2007.
  • Sourlas: Pavlos Sourlas, Legal Positivism and the Multifaceted Relationships of Law and Ethics, in: The Return of Ethics, Old and New Questions, edited by: Konstantinos Spatharakis and Stavros Zoumboulakis (Athens: Artos Zois Publications, 2013).
  • Schnä delbach: Herbert Schn ä delbach, “ Rationalit ä t und Begr ü ndung”, in the volume: Philosophie und Begr ü ndung (edited by Forum Philosophie Bad Homburg), Frankfurt, Suhrkamp, 1987
  • Stamelos Charalambos, Philosophy of Law – University Traditions, Law Library Edition, Athens 2020.
  • Stanford: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Jürgen Habermas”, https://plato.stanford.edu/ entries/habermas/ (21.09.2024).
  • Sfyroera: Sfyroera N. Sophia, The mythology of the Greeks vol. B’, Athens, Edition: Greek Letters, 2006.
  • Talbott: William Talbott, “Consequentialism and Human Rights”, in Wiley Online Library https://philpapers.org/rec/TALCAH (21/09/2024).
  • Toya: Toya V. Roussou E., Philosophical texts, Athens, Organization of Educational Books Publications of the Ministry of Education of Greece, Athens.
  • Tsatsos: Tsatsos Dimitrios, https://www.syntagmawatch.gr/trending-issues/oi-oroi-kratos-kai- politeia/ (19.9.2024)
  • Harakida:   Interview     with      Alexia     Harakida    –      Public      Constitutional   Law: https://greekhumans.com/synenteyxh-ths-alexias-xarakida-dhmosio-syntagmatiko-dikaio/ (17.9.2024)
  • Hammurabi: wikipedia . org ( https :// el . wikipedia . org / wiki / Hammurabi (19.9.2024) Hammurabi, 1910 English translation by LW King.
  • Walter: Burkert Walter , Greek Religion der archaishen und classic Epoche , translated by N.P. Bezantakos – Aphrodite Avagianou, Athens, Kardamitsa, 1993.
  • Weber: Max Weber , Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft (Chapter: „Rechtssoziologie“), editor: Johannes W Heinz Mohnhaupt , “ Potestas legislature und Gesetzesbegriff im Ancien Régime», Ius commune 4 (1973).